Lease vs. Buy: How to Decide What’s Right for You

Whether you're looking for the lowest payment, future flexibility, or long-term savings, deciding between leasing or buying a car is a major financial decision. This guide walks you through the real-life pros and cons—no jargon, no fluff—just what you need to know.

Evaluate Your Car Habits and Vehicle Condition

Be honest: Do you keep your car spotless, or is your bumper held on with a bungee cord?

  • Leasing requires you to return the car in like-new condition.
    • You may be charged for dings, scuffs, or wear unless you purchase XS Wear Protection.
  • Buying gives you the freedom to drive it as you please, no penalties.

If your vehicle ends up with a few battle scars, ownership may be smarter.

Consider Your Monthly Budget & Long-Term Plans

Ask yourself:

  • Are you looking for the lowest possible monthly payment?
  • Or do you want to own your vehicle outright someday?

Leasing

  • Lower monthly payments
  • Vehicle stays under warranty
  • No equity, ongoing payments if you lease again

Buying

  • Higher monthly payments upfront
  • Eventually payment-free once loan is paid
  • All maintenance and repairs are your responsibility after warranty ends

Leasing works great for budget-conscious shoppers who want a stress-free, short-term commitment.

How Much Do You Drive Each Year?

Mileage matters more than you think.

Typical Lease Allowances

  • 10,000 / 12,000 / 15,000 miles per year
  • Best lease rates usually come with lower mileage caps
  • Overage fees: ~$0.25/mile

Tips:

  • Don’t overestimate: Unused miles don’t get refunded
  • Trade or buyout options often bypass mileage penalties
  • If you drive 15k+ miles annually, buying is likely cheaper

Understand Lease Terms & Residual Value

Many lease deals look appealing—until you hit the buyout.

Example:

  • A $60,000 vehicle with a 78% residual over 24 months means you're only paying for 22% of the car
  • This creates very low monthly payments, but a high buyout cost at lease end
  • You can’t negotiate residual—it’s locked in your lease contract

Know your endgame before signing:Lease to return or lease to own?

Cash Upfront: Where It Goes

Purchasing

  • Any down payment reduces the loan amount
  • Builds equity from day one

Leasing

  • Due-at-signing is usually required
  • Cash upfront pre-pays monthly payments, not ownership
  • Larger upfront = lower monthly payment, but total cost remains the same

Example:

  • $68,000 vehicle
  • Lease: $2,999 due + $1,156/month = ~$41,616 total
  • Add $10,000 more upfront: new payment ~$878, total ~$31,616
  • Residual stays the same

Do You Like New Cars Often?

Some drivers love that new car smell every 2-3 years. If that’s you:

  • Leasing gives you fresh models with latest features
  • No negative equity if you exit cleanly
  • Always under warranty
  • Small wear/tear fees + $295 disposition fee if you don’t stay brand-loyal

Buying only makes sense if you’re ready to commit for 6+ years.

Credit Score and Debt-to-Income (DTI) Impact

Did you know a lease can look better on your credit than a loan?

  • Loan: Full balance shows as debt
  • Lease: Only the portion you're financing is reported

Example:

  • $40,000 car
  • Lease has $28,000 residual
  • Only $12,000 appears on your credit—great for DTI when applying for a home loan

Rebates, Loyalty Offers & Lease Specials

Lease deals often include

  • Extra rebates for existing lessees
  • Disposition fee waivers if staying brand loyal
  • Special EV incentives or tax credits (especially on GM models)

These extras can tip the scales toward leasing, especially with promotional programs.

Market Snapshot: 2025 Car Buying Trends

In today’s high-rate environment, more shoppers are leaning toward leasing:

  • Factory warranties reduce surprise expenses
  • Short-term leases shield buyers from depreciation
  • EVs often lease better due to inflated residual values

Vehicles like the Chevy Blazer EV are heavily incentivized—high residuals and bonus cash deals make short leases extremely attractive.

If You… Lease Buy
Want a lower monthly payment
Drive less than 12,000 miles/year
Want to avoid long-term commitments
Keep your car for 5+ years
Like customizing your car
Need the best credit-to-debt ratio