Lease vs. Buy: How to Decide What’s Right for You
Whether you're looking for the lowest payment, future flexibility, or long-term savings, deciding between leasing or buying a car is a major financial decision. This guide walks you through the real-life pros and cons—no jargon, no fluff—just what you need to know.
Evaluate Your Car Habits and Vehicle Condition
Be honest: Do you keep your car spotless, or is your bumper held on with a bungee cord?
- Leasing requires you to return the car in like-new condition.
- You may be charged for dings, scuffs, or wear unless you purchase XS Wear Protection.
- Buying gives you the freedom to drive it as you please, no penalties.
If your vehicle ends up with a few battle scars, ownership may be smarter.
Consider Your Monthly Budget & Long-Term Plans
Ask yourself:
- Are you looking for the lowest possible monthly payment?
- Or do you want to own your vehicle outright someday?
Leasing
- Lower monthly payments
- Vehicle stays under warranty
- No equity, ongoing payments if you lease again
Buying
- Higher monthly payments upfront
- Eventually payment-free once loan is paid
- All maintenance and repairs are your responsibility after warranty ends
Leasing works great for budget-conscious shoppers who want a stress-free, short-term commitment.
How Much Do You Drive Each Year?
Mileage matters more than you think.
Typical Lease Allowances
- 10,000 / 12,000 / 15,000 miles per year
- Best lease rates usually come with lower mileage caps
- Overage fees: ~$0.25/mile
Tips:
- Don’t overestimate: Unused miles don’t get refunded
- Trade or buyout options often bypass mileage penalties
- If you drive 15k+ miles annually, buying is likely cheaper
Understand Lease Terms & Residual Value
Many lease deals look appealing—until you hit the buyout.
Example:
- A $60,000 vehicle with a 78% residual over 24 months means you're only paying for 22% of the car
- This creates very low monthly payments, but a high buyout cost at lease end
- You can’t negotiate residual—it’s locked in your lease contract
Know your endgame before signing:Lease to return or lease to own?
Cash Upfront: Where It Goes
Purchasing
- Any down payment reduces the loan amount
- Builds equity from day one
Leasing
- Due-at-signing is usually required
- Cash upfront pre-pays monthly payments, not ownership
- Larger upfront = lower monthly payment, but total cost remains the same
Example:
- $68,000 vehicle
- Lease: $2,999 due + $1,156/month = ~$41,616 total
- Add $10,000 more upfront: new payment ~$878, total ~$31,616
- Residual stays the same
Do You Like New Cars Often?
Some drivers love that new car smell every 2-3 years. If that’s you:
- Leasing gives you fresh models with latest features
- No negative equity if you exit cleanly
- Always under warranty
- Small wear/tear fees + $295 disposition fee if you don’t stay brand-loyal
Buying only makes sense if you’re ready to commit for 6+ years.
Credit Score and Debt-to-Income (DTI) Impact
Did you know a lease can look better on your credit than a loan?
- Loan: Full balance shows as debt
- Lease: Only the portion you're financing is reported
Example:
- $40,000 car
- Lease has $28,000 residual
- Only $12,000 appears on your credit—great for DTI when applying for a home loan
Rebates, Loyalty Offers & Lease Specials
Lease deals often include
- Extra rebates for existing lessees
- Disposition fee waivers if staying brand loyal
- Special EV incentives or tax credits (especially on GM models)
These extras can tip the scales toward leasing, especially with promotional programs.
Market Snapshot: 2025 Car Buying Trends
In today’s high-rate environment, more shoppers are leaning toward leasing:
- Factory warranties reduce surprise expenses
- Short-term leases shield buyers from depreciation
- EVs often lease better due to inflated residual values
Vehicles like the Chevy Blazer EV are heavily incentivized—high residuals and bonus cash deals make short leases extremely attractive.
| If You… | Lease | Buy |
|---|---|---|
| Want a lower monthly payment | ✔ | |
| Drive less than 12,000 miles/year | ✔ | |
| Want to avoid long-term commitments | ✔ | |
| Keep your car for 5+ years | ✔ | |
| Like customizing your car | ✔ | |
| Need the best credit-to-debt ratio | ✔ |